About Us
Mission Advantage was founded to be a world class recruiting resource for nonprofits with ambitious missions.
The titans of business unanimously state that attracting, hiring, and retaining top talent is critical to success. Our passion is to help the most important organizations in the world – nonprofits – do just that.
We are not just recruiters. Our team is made up of seasoned nonprofit professionals who have served in the very sectors we now support: education, Catholic apostolates, dioceses and parishes, human services, philanthropic consulting, and beyond. Because we’ve walked in those shoes, we understand the unique challenges nonprofits face—and we’re uniquely equipped to find and place the mission-driven talent that helps them thrive.
Bill McGuckin | Co-founder & Managing Partner
Tom Pagano | Co-founder & President
Steve Mogle | Director of IT Recruiting
Will Panagakos | Talent Engagement Manager
John Glynn | Lead Recruiter
Joe Moran | Recruiter
Jess Foley | Director of Finance
Katelyn Chester | Sr. Market Consultant
Caleb Fitzgerald | Recruiter
Gabe Salamida | Recruiting Analyst
Steven Edwards | Recruiter
Catherine Pagano | Marketing & Brand Strategy Consultant
Elisa Hillman | Administrative Assistant
Michael Gieger | Account Executive
Tommy Lannen | Recruiter
We are proud to be an entity of The Oxenham Group, a world-class recruiting firm serving professional for-profit verticals. Through this partnership, Mission Advantage brings proven processes, an extensive talent network, and unbridled energy to the nonprofit recruiting space.