Executive Search & Recruiting
for nonprofits

Find a Job
Find Talent

The most impactful organizations in the world are only as strong as the people behind them. For nonprofits, the challenge is not just finding talent, but finding talent that truly believes in your specific mission. Mission Advantage Recruiting bridges that gap—helping organizations hire exceptional professionals who combine expertise, values, and a deep passion for mission.

Why does hiring matter for nonprofits?

  • Disengaged employees cost US organizations up to $550 billion per year.

    The Engagement Institute

  • Approx. 25% of new hires leave within the first 6 month, because the role is not aligned with expectations set in hiring process.

    Korn Ferry

  • Studies found that highly engaged employees are 87% less likely to leave their organization than their disengaged counterparts.

    Corporate Leadership Council

Learn about what we do differently

We are proud to serve mission-driven teams across industries

EWTN
Mary's Meals - A Simple Solution to World Hunger
Pushpay
Franciscan University of Steubenville
Catholic University of America
Hallow: A Catholic Prayer & Meditation App
Word on Fire
The Culture Project
Philos Project: Christian Advocacy in the Near East
Pioneer Catholic
Walking with Purpose: Catholic Bible Studies
Samaritan Ministries
Archdiocese of New York
Dynamic Catholic
Women's Care Center
Solidarity Healthshare
St. Paul Center for Biblical Theology
Koinonia Academy
Diocese of Metuchen
Roman Catholic Diocese of Sacramento
Agape Catholic Ministries
Logo of the Diocese of Tulsa and Eastern Oklahoma with a shield emblem and the slogan 'Together, our faith goes further'.
Logo for St. John's Bread & Life featuring a stylized design of three wheat stalks and the organization's name in gold text.
Logo of Cornerstone Schools featuring three green pillars and the text "Cornerstone Schools" in green.
Logo of St. Joseph Financial Services with the initials SJFS and a plus sign in the middle.
Logo of the Catholic Diocese of Pensacola-Tallahassee featuring a shield with a crown, windmill, heart, house, and chickens, with text below reading 'The Catholic Diocese of Pensacola-Tallahassee'.
Seton Hall University
FOCUS
The Napa Institute
Maimonides Medical Center
Logo of the Catholic News Agency (CNA) featuring a red globe with a cross and a map of the United States, alongside bold black text 'CNA' and smaller black text 'Catholic News Agency'.
Laudato Si' Movement | Catholics for Our Common Home
St. Benedict's Abbey
The Napa Institute
Archdiocese of Denver
Diocese of Toledo
The Diocese of Birmingham in Alabama
View Clients

Featured Jobs

  • Focus fellowship of Catholic university students logo in blue text on a white background.

    Chief People Officer

    Fellowship of Catholic University Students

    Denver, CO

    Learn More
  • Logo for the Diocese of San Jose

    Mission Advancement and Stewardship Director

    Diocese of San Jose

    San Jose, CA

    Learn More
  • Logo of the Angelicum

    Director of Annual Giving

    The Angelicum

    Remote

    Learn More

  • Director of Regional Development

    Holy Cross College at Notre Dame

    Remote

    Click Here